I just asked for my NMS refund today. Even though I have 40 hours playing it. I just... I couldn't find the fun parts for me.
I don't mind scouring mindlessly boring planet after mindlessly boring and meaningless planet.... AS LONG AS THERE'S SOME FORM OF PAY-OFF. Like in Diablo or Baldur's Gate. I don't mind getting 130 rusty long swords, plain as can be... as long as there's the PROMISE of getting one really kickass, talking sentient 2H sword, or a fire-breathing named weapon, or a life-sucking scythe with awesome art.
NMS has, literally, nothing special to ever find - EVER. Literally nothing. We all find the same Sigma, Tau and Theta upgrades for the same exact shield, blaster and laser as everyone else and there's never anything else, ever, for the whole game on all 18 quintillion planets, ever, forever.
God, it's such a drag, because the same exact thing extends to the creatures! Like, can you IMAGINE if the same were true in Star Control regarding the creeps on BIO worlds?????? Hah! What if the f-ing creeps were the ONLY aliens you EVER found in the entire game? Sure, the creeps are boring and just obstacles you need to overcome - but dang, if that was the WHOLE game? It would be worthless garbage.
But the creatures in NMS are even worse!! They do nothing and give you nothing - EVER. Yeah, they can poop or whatever, but who cares? You can find those minerals elsewhere. Shoot a creature you'll always just get carbon. So in SCII, it would be the equivalent of all creeps only ever giving you the dang greyish-blue element. Worthless.
I think that's where NMS missed a huge opportunity. It would be a million times better if SOME worlds had this race of extremely aggressive and vicious creatures living on the surface (or in the caves) that would just relentlessly hunt and attack you - but you'd go anyway because they guard all the Omegon! Right?? Instead, in 200 planets, I've found one species of crab that kind of moves toward me and hits me, without me even realizing it. Yeay.
Instead, they have the same mindless, 0-6 leg nothing-creatures with slightly different faces that don't care if you're there or not. What an awful, awful missed opportunity.
Frick, I could go on forever, but it's not worth tiring out my hands.