So in three threads, multiple days - multiple posts no one from Stardock has responded reference my issue. Beta 2.52 still doesn't fix the issue, and a version prior to 2.5 that worked isn't available for download. I will uninstall Start11 this weekend and test out Windhawk. I am fed up with Stardock's failure to respond and failure to provide the tools we need to use the software properly (IE older downloads) and so if Windhawk works I will vote with my wallet and cease to buy your products any longer. Nor will I renew my Multiplicity license when the time comes as there are alternatives for it as well I can use.
I want the taskbar at the top, and I need the right click flyout menu's for taskbar apps to work. And being ignored is just making me irate. I own a multipack for both Start11 and Multiplicity - for now. Bad support and customer service will push me to use alternatives.
I am sorry your post seems to have been missed amongst all the feedback.
If it helps I believe you would encounter other issues if you were to roll back to 2.11 as based on your OS version number you have now updated to a preview patch of 24H2 which alters how things work. This is the reason for the changes in v2.5.
Now to the issue in hand, given it only happens on one computer it seems likely there is something interfering with it.
The first thing I would try is set windows to use only the primary display and see if the problem continues (sign out and in again after changing). I suspect it will.
If so my best guess is something is interfering with how Start11 works in the newer versions. It would be enormously helpful if you can use the backup your settings option and send a copy of those settings as a private message to me. This lets us use the exact settings you are using and also contains a little debug info which can help diagnose problems.
The most likely cause of this would be some sort of shell / explorer extension.
It would also be interesting to know what happens if you were to set Windows to use a vertical taskbar on the primary. Where do the right click menus appear then?