Mystikmind Mystikmind

Why do Portable/external HDD stuff up??

Why do Portable/external HDD stuff up??

Hi

any of this sound familiar;

clicking noises, plugged in but not found, randomly picking files that will have hugely long transfer time, short lived, unreliable, cannot find files that exist, and all the rest of the nonsense i could not think of in this moment,,,, yes I'm talking about portable HDD here!!

I suppose this is partly a rant and partly a desperate question, "why god damn it, why????"

Why do portable HDD have to be ridiculous, and if your portable HDD is not ridiculous, you can bet it is thinking about doing it soon!

And what's worse, i have taken the most hopeless portable HDD doing all of the above mentioned nonsense, taken the drive out of the portable casing, installed it as an internal drive in a computer and suddenly the damn thing worked perfectly!!!!! WWWHHHYYY?

I have bought good quality ones, i have bought cheap ones, i have bought red ones and black ones, i have bought ones on the weekends and i have bought ones while wearing brown pants, neither nor here or there useless shit is their final destination each and every time.

But even as bad as things are in my experience, i have one friend who recently went through 4 portable HDD in one month, each one would stuff up and get returned at the shop,,, eventually they gave up returning them, after all, it was 'Seagate'!!! Even so, i would bet any one of those returned drives, if installed as an internal drive in a computer, they would work perfectly.

There is just something about HDD and a USB, i dunno, they just don't like each other for some reason,, kinda a bad match, like trying to force someone like John Wayne to be friends with someone like Osama Bin Laden!! Sooner or later the underlying dislike is going to start having an effect and no matter how you try and force them to work together, they just don't wanna!

 

Thoughts?

 

 

95,732 views 30 replies
Reply #26 Top

I am 40 years old and have had computers for the last 20. I have never had a HDD failure.  The only thing failing me was a usb stick that would not load (first time I used it, was empty). I guess I am just lucky. I have used Dell, Compaq (crappy computer, but HDD worked), Asus and IBM - desktop and laptops). 

Reply #27 Top

Quoting joasoze, reply 26
I guess I am just lucky.

A bit, yes.

HDs do fail.  Like people they too are mortal.  Dumbest ever reason for a fail was the dopey Comp shop who built my P100 way back when [It originally ran 3.11, not even 95] ....a whopping 1 gig drive that lasted "a few days" as they had soldered in the PC speaker [yes, that old] and shorted it to the chassis.  Who needs static issues when you have the entire case live with 5v .....

You could literally sit there and watch the bad sectors growing.......;p

Over the years I've had/seen about half a dozen drives at various levels of 'dead' ....;)

Reply #28 Top

Quoting Jafo, reply 27

Quoting joasoze, reply 26I guess I am just lucky.

A bit, yes.

HDs do fail.  Like people they too are mortal.  Dumbest ever reason for a fail was the dopey Comp shop who built my P100 way back when [It originally ran 3.11, not even 95] ....a whopping 1 gig drive that lasted "a few days" as they had soldered in the PC speaker [yes, that old] and shorted it to the chassis.  Who needs static issues when you have the entire case live with 5v .....

You could literally sit there and watch the bad sectors growing.......

Over the years I've had/seen about half a dozen drives at various levels of 'dead' ....

 

You had a 1 gig drive back when people would say 'wow' to a 50mb drive!!!!????

Reply #29 Top

Quoting Mystikmind, reply 28
You had a 1 gig drive back when people would say 'wow' to a 50mb drive!!!!????

No.  at the time the largest currently available was 1.2 gig ... I think, but like any other time the biggest/best was at a premium so I opted for something smaller.

My first PC had a 40 meg drive... it was an IBM XT clone.

Reply #30 Top

Quoting Jafo, reply 29

Quoting Mystikmind, reply 28You had a 1 gig drive back when people would say 'wow' to a 50mb drive!!!!????

No.  at the time the largest currently available was 1.2 gig ... I think, but like any other time the biggest/best was at a premium so I opted for something smaller.

My first PC had a 40 meg drive... it was an IBM XT clone.

 

my timing a bit off... anyway, My first pc had no HDD at all! an Amiga 2000, then later i got an Amiga 1200 with a 40mb hdd