TheScottishAlien TheScottishAlien

Community on the Edge

Community on the Edge

Many many post on the forums are currently sinking into depression.  Cries that the developers have abandoned us.. that frogboy don't care.. or that demigods have been back shelved for newer projects.  These are specifically coming from the lack of feedback of any sort coming from SD or GPG. 

lack of content combined with unfixed bugs and no ETA for any new patches has really stunted the communities growth. Along with other MOBA (Multiplayer Online Battle Arena) games coming out like LoL and HoN there has been a steady increase of regular forum posters saying their fairwells and goodbyes. 

before it was really Frogboy that kept us going though the real painful months after release.  constant reminders and posts as well as good discussion in the journals really kept the communities spirits lifted until the release of V1.1 .  unfortunately for the majority of us, some of the more trolling posters really chipped away at Frogboy and since he's return form vacation we've seen little to no activity from his end.

sure we, as the community, complain and complain about content and bug... and no amount of this complaining will speed up production in any way, but it was always nice to at least have regular posts telling us all to STFU.  the silent treatments (or what ever this is) is currently not just hurting the Demigod Community but also driving people away from future releases of games.

all we are asking for is a little attention and a bit of a reminder that we have not been abandoned by SD or GPG.  without a healthy relationship between the dev's and the community this game does not have a very bright future, so to keep that from happening (which no one wants to see) we would really like to see some responces from the dev's to at least let us know they still care.

30,211 views 54 replies
Reply #26 Top

Quoting ZehDon, reply 24
You guys are aware, of course, that Frogboy actually told us that his involvement in the Demigod community would be lessened once the connectivity issues were fixed, right? It has nothing to do with Trolls or the continual and unfounded negative comments, or with Stardock and Gas Powered Games "turning their back" on the Demigod community. The last update to Demigod was released two weeks ago. Seriously, how much babying do you guys want? Let's get some realistic expectations.

The negative attitudes of some of the people in this thread, such as:
There used to be 3000+ people online, now its rare to see much more than 2000. If you asked me, the community is not on the edge, most have already jumped...
are the typical "ZOMG SKY IS FALLING" attitude that is a persistant force on the forums of many games these days and it's kept alive and well by the simple fact that people don't see what's going on behind the scenes.

If you're unhappy with the treatment of the community, and frankly I think we've been pampered, then leave. You're quite welcome to stay, but for the love of all that is holy can we please stop with these "ZOMG DEMGOD IZ DED!!11ELEVEN! GPGSD R DRINKN OUR T3ARZ!!11!ELEVEN" threads. The game is three months old. If nothing changes in another three months, then you've got some ammunition. When the last update was released less than a month ago, in the realm of PC gaming, the game is considered very much still "Supported".

 

QFT. These sky is falling threads are getting old.

Reply #27 Top

Ok, maybe is just a phase, like the "RAGEQUITTING!" one, or "REGULUS OP!"

So yeah, now i think it will be over soon...this situation, not the game.

Reply #28 Top

agreed, every time i come on the forums i expect the dev's to jump out form what ever rock they've been hiding under with a grin on their faces and content to be uploaded.  however that isn't the point at all of my post.  there is a big difference between a game doing bad and fail which i think needs clearing up.

i think the game will do bad without proper a developer to consumer relationship

definition of doing bad: reduced sales with a slow, stagnent community.  poor update and content due to lack of feedback and input form the community

now the definition of failing: developers have to pull support due to little to no sales resulting in the colapse of online support and gameplay.

 

now the game will not fail because SD states that GP was binded by contract for longterm commitment to this game, that is a fact.  my point for this post is that SD and GPG need ot both realize that the relationship needed between Dev's and Consumers needs to a lot more than a regular game.  most games release one patch every 6-18 months and have little to no content, ever. 

this is a MOBA which is built on two things:  Content, and Balances.  content means a steady flow of ideas coming from the community and a stead amount of feedback form the dev's.  balancing requires a heavy online player base to test and narrow down imbalances and bugs so dev's can quickly fix and update the game.  for both of these dev's need to be heavily active in the forums to ideas can be properly developed and so bugs and fixes can be prioritized and fixed.

currently we are not seeing that kind of activity from the dev's and a lot of people are pissed.  agreed it's only been 2 weeks since the last patch but this is a crucial time for dev's to get feedback on what was done right and wrong by the pathc, and what to do right for the next one.  that is my point, dev's need to give feedback so the community can grow and develop

Reply #29 Top

And this is on a Friday night too. This game is dead.


Demigod Server Stats

Stats are updated every minute. Last updated on: 7/18/2009 2:42:29 AM

 

Open Games Current Games Players Online
5 41

236

Reply #30 Top

I have noticed a sharp drop in game,s yeah, which is unfortunate.

Reply #31 Top

Let's not spread crap. Every once in a while Stardock's ISP takes a dump. Do yourself a favor and check the stats again 15 minutes later.

Reply #32 Top

I didn't say the game was dea,d just noting it wa s aquiet night.

 

Which is probably attributed to being a Friday Night. People are out doing things.

Reply #33 Top

Quoting TormakSaber, reply 7
I didn't say the game was dea,d just noting it wa s aquiet night.

 

Which is probably attributed to being a Friday Night. People are out doing things.

 

Yeah, like playing WoW probably. :rofl:

Reply #34 Top

The opengames.aspx got overwritten by the old one that only lists people on the beta server. I've sent an email.

See my Friday update to get an idea where things stand.

Reply #35 Top

Quoting Frogboy, reply 9
The opengames.aspx got overwritten by the old one that only lists people on the beta server. I've sent an email.

See my Friday update to get an idea where things stand.

You proved me wrong Mr. Wardell. I can admit when I was mistaken, and I'm glad I was wrong as I do indeed love this game.

I noticed the page changed.

Open Games Current Games Players Online
10 68 2570
Reply #36 Top

Yea, I sent an email in about it and got them to get the other page up.

Also, as someone else pointed out, I didn't intend to hang out too much once the connectivity got fixed.  The other communities get jealous. :)

Reply #37 Top

don't leave :'( what will we do when we have questions? or need an occasional pat on the back to cheer us up?...

 

well if u are going to leave can u at least drop by form time to time so we can catch up... for old times sakes?

Reply #38 Top

Oh I'm not leaving. I just can't be making posts every day and such.  

It seems like if I'm gone a few days we start seeing posts asserting that Demigod has been "abandoned" which I and others here find maddening given how much daily work is going on for Demigod both at Stardock and at Gas Powered Games.

I think we got a new build in from GPG every day this week.  But those builds have to go through QA and be checked for bugs and such.

It's a damned if you do, damned if you don't situation.  When we have pushed rapid updates, bugs get through and people scream about the "crappy QA".  If we hold back and put updates through a thorough QA to eliminate bugs, we get "What's the ETA on the next patch?!" posts with claims of abandonment.

The next patch will come out when it's ready. :)

Reply #39 Top

well having a look at when u posted your last 2 journals:

 

I'm Back --> posted July 8th

Weekend Upate  --> posted July 18th

 

so thats around ten days of "silence" and i think the major "abandonment posts" came around the the 15th so about a week.  i think as a minimum if we could just get one new journal enry a week (and they can be complete recaps for all i care) then i think the community will be saisfied.  of course more than that and we're laughing but is all about ur time vs our demands.

 

Reply #40 Top

IMO, the problem is that it's hard to see what GPG is doing. Gameplay changing typos that have been in since Beta are still there; as far as the players know, GPG is just plain slow.

 

:fox:

Reply #41 Top

Perhaps a simple lil shoutbox-style updater somewhere would help ease the fears of abandonment?  Just a passworded form for the devs that stores the timestamp and a quick message.  So then someone at GPG could just punch in "demigod 1.2 alpha 3 testing done" or whatnot, and click the submit button -- takes a few seconds, and people who need to be reminded that things are really happening are hopefully satisfied.

Reply #42 Top

Quoting Kitkun, reply 15
IMO, the problem is that it's hard to see what GPG is doing. Gameplay changing typos that have been in since Beta are still there; as far as the players know, GPG is just plain slow.

 

 

This I think is it. On these forums we see Satrdock Stardock Stardock. Of course we do, these are Stardock forums!

If GPG could even give a cursory glance at these forums, even just one post here and there, something to let us see that they're not just shoving the entire PR/Community side to stardock to deal with, I think a lot of shoulders would have burdens taken off them.

When transparency is replaced with a big heavy curtain with messages of "It's coming when it comes", people get antsy and irritated. A simple post can make all the difference sometimes.

Reply #43 Top

IMO, the problem is that it's hard to see what GPG is doing. Gameplay changing typos that have been in since Beta are still there; as far as the players know, GPG is just plain slow.

WTB a WoW style PTR patch notes, so we can see what GPG are working on :)

Reply #44 Top

we need to have a community wide call out for some GPG posts...

"Come on GPG, i dare u to post in here!"

lol ;P

Reply #45 Top

Quoting Frogboy, reply 13

The next patch will come out when it's ready.

 

I think we have heard that outlook from a very successful game developer, I once compared the customer/developer support of Stardock with that of said computer game giant (hint: Starts with a B .) and that is truely right out of their vocab books.

I will continue to support Demigod, and Stardock, as I am well aware it is not their hands that hold the additional content that we have been seeking/promised. I will not, however, purchase another Gas Powered Games product - due to the fact that they have dropped the ball hidiously with their support for content for Demigod. I will pay for Demigods and Maps no problem, no questions, no hassels, and I know a lot of others will as well - so where is the DLC??

Frogboy and Stardock cant make Demigods, they cant make maps, they cant make items, they cant add some additional spells to our current Demigods to increase the amount of different builds. This is all GPG, and I am excited for the modding ability to reach the players, however, I can almost guarentee with my bank account that the second modding is released for Demigod, GPG will pull out of all GPG Released Additional Demigods.

In conclusion, I must say, Stardock, once again, always a great company - Doing EVERYTHING they can to make us happy. We had problems, we had issues, SD fixed them within the week, another issue poped up, fixed within a week.

Gas Powered Games - the taste in my mouth is fouler then shit, have fun developing your Sup Com 2, maybe you won't abandon that community for your NEXT project...

PS: I hope Sup Com 2 tanks so hard, I would love to see that community rip you apart as well GPG.

- Mord

Reply #46 Top

A lot of posts in this thread. Notice GPG have made revenue from the game in its current state. Repairing the game and using resources to 'enhance' the game past what it is currently would remove that margin of revenue and eventually erode at GPG bottom line. So the bottom line is, this game is as good as its gonna get. In there world, it is 100% finished, playable, released and purchased by the public. The connectivity is good enough to play, and there are enough DG and Maps that you aren't only playing 1 person each match.

Sorry to disapoint any avid DG players out there, but the only good games for communities to advocate are open sourceand indie games. Corperations are always after the $, not creating something unique for a community to enjoy for a long time.

Reply #47 Top

Quoting Frogboy, reply 13
Oh I'm not leaving. I just can't be making posts every day and such.  

It seems like if I'm gone a few days we start seeing posts asserting that Demigod has been "abandoned" which I and others here find maddening given how much daily work is going on for Demigod both at Stardock and at Gas Powered Games.

I think we got a new build in from GPG every day this week.  But those builds have to go through QA and be checked for bugs and such.

It's a damned if you do, damned if you don't situation.  When we have pushed rapid updates, bugs get through and people scream about the "crappy QA".  If we hold back and put updates through a thorough QA to eliminate bugs, we get "What's the ETA on the next patch?!" posts with claims of abandonment.

The next patch will come out when it's ready.

That's all we want to hear =)

Reply #48 Top

Quoting alvaro202, reply 21
A lot of posts in this thread. Notice GPG have made revenue from the game in its current state. Repairing the game and using resources to 'enhance' the game past what it is currently would remove that margin of revenue and eventually erode at GPG bottom line. So the bottom line is, this game is as good as its gonna get. In there world, it is 100% finished, playable, released and purchased by the public. The connectivity is good enough to play, and there are enough DG and Maps that you aren't only playing 1 person each match.

Sorry to disapoint any avid DG players out there, but the only good games for communities to advocate are open sourceand indie games. Corperations are always after the $, not creating something unique for a community to enjoy for a long time.

That's not how computer games should work. You should support the game for years and build a community. But what do Blizzard and Valve know, they're obviously terrible at doing this and are not rolling in money. I guess GPG doesn't like money.

Reply #49 Top

Quoting alvaro202, reply 21
A lot of posts in this thread. Notice GPG have made revenue from the game in its current state. Repairing the game and using resources to 'enhance' the game past what it is currently would remove that margin of revenue and eventually erode at GPG bottom line. So the bottom line is, this game is as good as its gonna get. In there world, it is 100% finished, playable, released and purchased by the public. The connectivity is good enough to play, and there are enough DG and Maps that you aren't only playing 1 person each match.

Sorry to disapoint any avid DG players out there, but the only good games for communities to advocate are open sourceand indie games. Corperations are always after the $, not creating something unique for a community to enjoy for a long time.

I wasn't aware you worked at GPG and had copies of their internal documentation relating to their thoughts on Demigod. However, I don't think you do considering GPG is an independant Developer, and if you had "inside" knowledge you'd have known that. I think GPG are a little disheartened if anything; and not just from the teething issues that Demigod has. Seeing crap like this posted on the forums can't exactly fill them with confidence.

Reply #50 Top

Quite frankly, if people posted like this every few days that I didn't send them word that I was working, I'd actually abandon them. With all these chickens running around claiming the sky has fallen, I'm surprised their noise hasn't knocked a rafter loose.