Dual booting Vista onto an XP machine?

Is installing Vista on a second partionion probematic so I can have a dual boot system?

3,043 views 13 replies
Reply #1 Top

I've seen it beening done by some skinners so they can make WindowBlinds for both XP and Vista.  I would think that a HDD of sufficient size to allow enough space for each OS is the first thing you want to have.  I could be wrong about this but I believe there is even software available that assists you is setting up a dual boot system.

You might want to visit the IRC and the Stardock Channel, more then likely you will get a quick answer. 

Reply #2 Top

Thanks Philly,  I guess Vista to W7 is going to be the only way to upgrade so I thought I'd give it a go while I can get a cheap OEM copy of Vista Home Premium.  Or maybe I should just wait for the full version of W7.  I don't know which might be more cost effective.

Reply #3 Top

I just did a internet search for Dual Boot, came up with alot of stuff that probably would help.  Give it a try.

Just out of curosity, why do you want to dual boot?

I think I read that you would be able to go from XP to Windows 7, though probably not as easy or inexpensive as going from Vista to Windows 7.

Are you ready for a new computer?  It might be least expensive then to just wait and upgrade to a new computer when Windows 7 is realeased.

Reply #4 Top

Thanks Philly, I guess Vista to W7 is going to be the only way to upgrade so I thought I'd give it a go while I can get a cheap OEM copy of Vista Home Premium. Or maybe I should just wait for the full version of W7. I don't know which might be more cost effective.

Vista to Win 7 would be the easier upgrade than XP to Win 7, but upgrading from XP to Vsta is not necessarily the best or cheapest way, particularly if you have to upgrade your hardware because Vista is more resource intensive. If your current rig isn't powerful enough to cope with the requirements of Vista, then you may be better off saving your money and waiting to get the full version of Win 7, which is less resource intensive than Vista and should run well enough on most modern machines.

Let's put it this way, if your current rig needs hardware upgrades to handle Vista properly - that's a double expense that's tripled when you upgrade again to Win 7 -  then you would probably be better off waiting for Win 7 to be realeased and getting a full version at a fractionally higher price than an upgrade edition.

I suppose, too, it depends on your current hardware and whether or not it is sufficient to run Win 7, because if it isn't, you would need to weigh up the pros and cons of upgrading your hardware to accomodate Win 7, or buying a new rig with it pre-installed.  I know that MS had a utility people could use to to test their PC's for Vista upgradability but I haven't seen one as yet for Win 7; however, that would answer some of your questions if there is one.... should I discover one I'll be in touch.

:)

Reply #5 Top

Quoting starkers, reply 4

Thanks Philly, I guess Vista to W7 is going to be the only way to upgrade so I thought I'd give it a go while I can get a cheap OEM copy of Vista Home Premium. Or maybe I should just wait for the full version of W7. I don't know which might be more cost effective.
Vista to Win 7 would be the easier upgrade than XP to Win 7, but upgrading from XP to Vsta is not necessarily the best or cheapest way, particularly if you have to upgrade your hardware because Vista is more resource intensive. If your current rig isn't powerful enough to cope with the requirements of Vista, then you may be better off saving your money and waiting to get the full version of Win 7, which is less resource intensive than Vista and should run well enough on most modern machines.

Let's put it this way, if your current rig needs hardware upgrades to handle Vista properly - that's a double expense that's tripled when you upgrade again to Win 7 -  then you would probably be better off waiting for Win 7 to be realeased and getting a full version at a fractionally higher price than an upgrade edition.

I suppose, too, it depends on your current hardware and whether or not it is sufficient to run Win 7, because if it isn't, you would need to weigh up the pros and cons of upgrading your hardware to accomodate Win 7, or buying a new rig with it pre-installed.  I know that MS had a utility people could use to to test their PC's for Vista upgradability but I haven't seen one as yet for Win 7; however, that would answer some of your questions if there is one.... should I discover one I'll be in touch.

Starkers is correct.I daul boot XP & Vista on the PC I build WB's on not a problem Vista will even see the files in the XP partition but remeber to leave space Vista is not only resource hungry but it is big deppending on the version up to 20 gigs just for Vista.Hope it helps! ;) :)

Reply #6 Top

I don't know which might be more cost effective.

Only time can tell. It is unfotunate that we have to wait for time but time doesn't wait for us. At the same time it is fortunate because had it not been the case all actions will cease to exist.

 

So in my view, you might wish to wait.

I havn't dual boot XP and Vista but you can learn it here. and Please read the 'Page 6' there.

 

Reply #7 Top

This is what i did to Duel Boot Vista/Win7 ....... follow this and you'll be fine

 

1- free partition program EASEUS partition manager home edition 3.0  (just Google to find it)

2 - set up partition for 2nd OS (i used 30Gigs for Win7) or any amount you want

3- oldest OS must go first i.e. ( Xp/Vista or Vista/Win7 )

4- once new partition is set up ( YOU MUST ) format it with Windows Format

    so use Xp win format to format new partition for Vista - must do this for OS to take

5- now your ready to load Vista on the new partition 

6- now when you boot up Windows will give you 2 OS's to boot from Vista 1st and Xp 2nd ...

...... any questions let me know  - i have the partition program if needed i can e-mail to ya ..... AzDude

 

IMPORTANT : of course do a complete backup of all important things (always) before messin' with OS ...

Reply #8 Top

What file system for XP and Vista?

Should both be NTFS?

Will XP on FAT32 and Vista on NTFS work?

Reply #9 Top

I use NTSF on both 

Reply #10 Top

I used Vista to create the second partition,(administrative tools-computer management) then booted off win7 dvd, and installed it without a hitch to the partition that i had created using vista, it actually took less time to install win7 than vista

Reply #11 Top

Microsoft does say that Win 7 will upgrade over XP so that is a logn term option to think about at least. Lots of people dual boot and have given you very good outlines of the process, I see.

Drive space is very much a concern because Vista is aa huge install.

I wouldn't recommend Fat32 regardless of the combination of XP and Vista. NTFS is a much more reliable file system in just about every way.

Reply #12 Top

I wouldn't recommend Fat32 regardless of the combination of XP and Vista. NTFS is a much more reliable file system in just about every way.

I may be wrong here, but I don't think you can use the FAT system in Vista anyway... I think it installs as NTFS by default due to the OS size, etc.... same with Win 7.  In fact, drives/partitions over a certain size (been a while so I can't remember exactly) are automatically assigned the NTFS file system, due to FAT becoming unstable on larger drives.

As for upgrading to Win 7 from XP (or Vista), is the option still there to do a clean install, where setup asks you to insert your previous OS disk to show eligibility, like it was with the XP upgrade?  If that is possible with Win 7, then that would be the preferable way to go as the new OS is not inheriting and anomolies from the old one.

Also, for those on older machines who are unsure if Win 7 will run properly, does anyone know if MS has released a tool (like they did for Vista) that assesses the current hardware configuration for Win 7 operability/suitability?  I've not seen one as yet, but one would be very useful for those considering an upgrade to Win 7 on older machines.... though it's probably not as big an issue due to Win7 being a smaller intall and using less resources than Vista does.

Reply #13 Top

I'd highly recommend downloading Virtual PC 2007 SP1.  That way you don't need to dual boot.  You can just run a Virtual Machine.

 

Check it out here:  http://www.microsoft.com/downloadS/details.aspx?FamilyID=28c97d22-6eb8-4a09-a7f7-f6c7a1f000b5&displaylang=en

 

If you have any issues with it, post here and I can help you thoroughly thought the setup and usage process of it.