CharlesCS CharlesCS

Need a new external drive, any ideas?

Need a new external drive, any ideas?

Need some help in deciding what external drive I should get. I currently have a 500 GB SATA drive in an external USB case and a 250 GB Western Digital passport. I have lots of music, pictures and video files and am looking to put them all in a central storage location where I can access all of them thru my network but still keep it portable.

Here are some of the options I am looking at, I'm just not sure which to chose.

Seagate Freeagent - Enough space, great price but read it has a power issue by many buyers.

Western Digital My Book
- Also lot's of space plus extra connections, price is not bad would like more space but will cost a lot more.

Maxtor OneTouch
- Lot's of space and a great price, would like more space but cant find anything bigger at the moment. Don't know much about Maxtor external drives so please any personal reviews would be great.

Keep in mind, the links are not necessarily where I will purchase these products. I also wonder if it would be better and cheaper if I simply got an internal drive to match the 500 GB I currently have (maybe a 1TB) and a new external case to accommodate both drives.

Any information will be greatly appreciated.
69,157 views 32 replies
Reply #26 Top

I use Mybooks.. never had a single issue, been using for over a year.

Ditto.   :grin:

Reply #28 Top

BTW, a question. Is it possible to have a hard drive connected thru both a usb and an ethernet at the same time? Just wondering.

A hard drive connected via ethernet would be a new one on me. Never heard of it. *_*

Reply #29 Top

I've had a Maxtor OneTouch 300GB USB 2.0.  Installed easily and runs great.

Reply #31 Top

Quoting JcRabbit, reply 24
USB only, write transfer rate about 25.8 GB/s

Damn, I want me one of those!

What's that, USB 5.0?

Reply #32 Top

:grin:  lol, sorry, confused my GigaBytes with my MegaBytes. :P I meant MB/s, obviously. :)

25 GB/s... now THAT would be something! My 500 GB full system backup would be finished in 20 seconds, hehe :thumbsup: