Ive been hosting "team picking" 4v4s , Hosts should do this
Host chooses 2 Captains with highest stats. Teams are picked once game is full . Teams are as balanced as can be.
Ive been hosting Team picking hosted games for awhile now, and I have to say the feedback has been very positive. Alot of players have commented that although noob stomping is fun for atleast 4 of the 8 players , a fierce balanced battle is fun for all 8 players regardless of who wins or lose. Infact I see alot less "quitting" and more players fighting it out to the death.
Picking is especially good when theres obviously two fresh newbies occupying the bottom 4 slots (happens alot). Fresh Newbies in Sins are mostly well behaved and will tell the host (me) that they are indeed completely fresh. Ive seen time and time again with other hosts who do top v bottom that they ignore the fact that theres 2 newbies on one side , because for them ,they will still have just as much fun from a noob stomp. If team picking occurs , then there will be 1 newbie on each side. The competant players will know that both teams will have a newbie so they dont have to rage on the newbie to perform above expectations. The newbie can also relax knowing that it wont be all his fault if the team loses as theres a newbie on the other team.
Picking Team 4v4s are the way to go . Its fun for everyone. Please ALL hosts do this.
ps - team picking 4v4s was inspired by CenturionJixras post on Pug IRC games