Sesame Street, bad for my child?

In today's world...

I was amazed to hear the news reporter quip "there's a warning about Sesame Street, it might not be good for your child", then went to commercial! Don't you just love it when they do that?! Then you hang on til they come back and read the story at the end of the next half hour!

It's not really the current episodes of Sesame Street that are bad for your children, it's the versions from 40 or so years ago. There are now Volumes I & II out on DVD that features story-lines, or skits that might not be suitable for your child to see because it might let them do or believe the wrong thing! So the producers have put a warning lable on them.

One of the scenes on the DVD is a stranger met little "Sally" (not the right name) on the road and took her home to meet his wife. While Sally did not go inside their house, she stayed outside, and the couple were very friendly and nice, then the wife invited Sally to come back to visit with them again. Do you see what's wrong with that picture? Yep, 'stranger danger" the warnings that we now give our children, back in 1969, that was not necessary to do! In today's world it is!

There is a scene of Cookie Monster gobbling up, quite greedily, some cookies; the children might get the wrong impression and think that being obsessed with sweet, sugary cookies is a good thing! In today's world it's not! Childhood obesity is a very big (pardon the pun) and ugly problem these days!

Oscar the Grouch is very depressed and quite angry in one scene. You remember how Oscar is right? The grouchy, curmudgeonly character that we used to get a laugh from because of his grumpy antics? Not cute and funny anymore! In today's world, Oscar is considered manic depressive and that is not a good thing for children to see! We don't want them to know that people do have good and bad days!

Back in the day, when my siblings and I used to sit down and watch with avid adoration those little muppets and puppets and people on that beloved show, we didn't worry about stuff like that! It wasn't necessary then, but it is now, in today's world!

It's a sad state of affairs indeed!"
10,649 views 29 replies
Reply #1 Top

Oh bullshit.  The only one I agree with is the stranger one...other than that being grumpy and eating cookies is hardly a horrible thing.  They're freaking puppets.  I honestly don't think just cookies will lead to a fat kid...other foods must be added(greasey fast food, candy, a whole host of other junk) unless there's someone that keeps literally cabinets and cabinets full of cookies and refuses to limit their kid's diet.  As for being grouchy?  The man lives in a garbage can...I think if anyone is allowed to be pissed at the world it's that guy.

~Zoo

Reply #2 Top

Rolls Eyes...  Nothing but adults thinking like adults when watching a kids' show.  It's right up there with Popeye cartoons having to "eplain" where Swea' Pea came from and Bert & Ernie being gay.

If you ask me, Sesame Street has gone way Down Hill in the last decade or so, not gotten better.

Reply #3 Top
And, and, and, in one episode, it shows a woman breastfeeding! We wouldn't want our kids to see that, right???
Reply #4 Top
Sesame street doesn't hold my son's attention.  It's tired compared to the other vibrant shows aimed at the same audience.
Reply #5 Top
Reply #6 Top

Cookie monster was an obsessive cookie eater when I was a kid.  You know what though?  I never once thought it would be fun to eat that many cookies... watching that I knew it would make me really sick.

Oscar should stay grumpy.  It's his character.

Bert & Ernie don't need to be gay, or straight, or anything either.

Good lord, maybe we're becoming too protective of kids these days.

Reply #7 Top
I grew up watching Sesame Street, plus the whole line up of shows that followed on PBS. Everything from 3-2-1 Contact, Reading Rainbow and Mr Rogers. It didn't make me go into strangers house, be grouchy and eat all the cookies I could in a single bit.

I just love how all these warnings are needed to make up for the lack of parental responsibility. Instead of working towards a future were strangers should not be dangerous people, we bunch together the good people with the bad people and tell our kids trust no one. Innocent till proven guilty? It seems that this country is doing a great job at erasing everything that made this country such a great country.
Reply #8 Top
Good lord, maybe we're becoming too protective of kids these days.


Tell me about it. Keep this up and even a character like Sportacus for the TV show Lazy Town (my 4 year old loves this show) will eventually be considered bad for children. The guy is a super athlete that likes to jump around a lot , do flips and is nearly perfect at any sport. I guess it's a matter of time before someone sees him as dangerous because children will want to jump and do flips like him and could get hurt, and he may make children who are not really good at sports feel bad cause they can't do what he can.

We are definitely spiraling down to a senseless society.
Reply #9 Top
Tell me about it. Keep this up and even a character like Sportacus for the TV show Lazy Town (my 4 year old loves this show) will eventually be considered bad for children.
End of quote


hahaha. When I first saw the show I thought....WHERE are her parents? Why is she running around town with this man? And why does this adult man play with kids? I wouldn't let me daughter run around with some uber goober man like that....hahahahahaha

I do think its a matter of perspective. I don't think it teaches kids to talk to strangers or hang out with adults. They see the fun, the singing and dancing....I saw the other because I have the parent perspective and ya gotta admit...little girls playing with men in tights who lift them in the air and stuff....kinda weird..
Reply #10 Top
Its really amazing. I grew up watching Sesame St. and I think it was a positive influence. None of us shot up schools or went on rampages like some modern kids who watched Barney and other PC crap.
Reply #11 Top
Did things change so fast within a generation in the past, or is it just with us?


I can see the concern about stranger-danger: the sasame street world is a trusting place with no bad people at all. But what are you going to do, teach children that the world is all about people out to get them? Isn't the latter worse?

I always thought Sasame street was at most showing what the world could be rather than what it is.

I always liked Cookie Monster. But even as a child, I noticed that when he gobbled them like he did, all the cookies ended up as crumbs on the floor. Are children that dumb that they will take muppets seriously? They can't blame Cookie Monster for obesity -- they ought to blame MacD's for their ads and those attractive happy meals aimed at children, and parents who give in.

For fark's sake, Oscar isn't a manic depressive -- he's at most just someone who likes to find something to complain about. I sometimes thought of him as a realist who brings balance to the sometimes over-optimistic population of that show.
Reply #12 Top
Maybe in 40 years someone will be complaining about todays kid shows. I just want to know who would want to watch all that old stuff now? I looks so dated. I was facinated by Speed Racer in the 60's when I was a kid. About a year and a half ago I bought all the epps on DVD, still haven't finished them (some are pretty bad). Just goes to show you things change, no matter how much we wish they wouldn't.
Reply #13 Top
I never had them overdose on cookies...hahahah but I can't say they didn't get grouchy on occasion. I'm sure it had nothing to do with Oscar. Hmmmmmm maybe it did and I was a bad mother by letting them watch this?

Maybe if I didn't allow them to watch this bad show twice a day everyday I would never have had grumpy kids. It's all my fault.


Gah!


What about Elmo? Is there anything wrong with him? Because I was thinking of getting little Ethan an Elmo? But do you think Elmo is....welll.....errrrr....too happy?
Reply #14 Top
What about Elmo? Is there anything wrong with him? Because I was thinking of getting little Ethan an Elmo? But do you think Elmo is....welll.....errrrr....too happy?
End of quote


Just make sure it's a tickle me Elmo, not a tickle me EMO. :LOL:

Reply #15 Top
Just make sure it's a tickle me Elmo, not a tickle me EMO.
End of quote


That was the best minute and a half of my day. :)

~Zoo
Reply #16 Top

Just make sure it's a tickle me Elmo, not a tickle me EMO.
End of quote


ya, ain't that the truth. I like happy Elmo much better. EMO is too depressing.

Reply #17 Top
Irony: The people who complain about Oscar are just like him.
Reply #18 Top
Oh I loved Speed Racer and 3-2-1 Contact and Reading Rainbow and Mr. Rogers! My kids came to enjoy Speed Racer and Reading Rainbow and Mr. Rogers too! 3-2-1 Contact doesn't show on television anymore. Anyone remember the Electric Company? There were some wonderful kids show back in the day!


I think our world has gotten too politically correct that we can't tell the difference between what's good for our children and what's not good for them. In fact, I think too many of us are listening to those idiots who can't tell the difference anymore. The fact that Cookie Monster could be the cause for child obesity? Yea right! That's what they talked about on the report! Someone mentoned parental responsibility? Yes, that's what it takes, parents being involved and not just giving in to the children, at least doing so within realistic goals.

Whip I would hate to think that Oscar couldn't be Oscar anymore! The reality of our world is that people aren't always happy. They whine and get angry and get depressed too, that's being human, we aren't all perfect and I guess the PC club has forgotten that!

The thing is what has our world come to that the producers have to put a warning lable on a children's DVD because they might get the wrong idea? Why can't our children just be children and enjoy being children? Sad state of affairs!

Reply #19 Top

I am not surprised, but I am veyr saddened by the whole PC crap that passes for overbearing government intrusion in our lives.  Sesame Street is just one very glaring example, but hardly the only one or the most extreme.

This is where good intentions get you to.

Reply #20 Top
I am not surprised, but I am veyr saddened by the whole PC crap that passes for overbearing government intrusion


Not just government intrusion, private people in companies or/and organizations who think they know what's good for all of us!
Reply #21 Top

My babysitter and I were talking about this the other day.  I can understand the "stranger danger" one but the rest is just upsetting.  Whatever happened to childhood silliness.  Kids know the difference between what a "monster" does and what they should do.  "Cookie Monster" is just that, a monster that gobbles up cookies.  Kids know that it is just silliness and find it funny.

When all adult forget what it's like to be a kid, all is lost.  Luckily there are enough of us who refuse to "grow up".

Reply #22 Top
When all adult forget what it's like to be a kid, all is lost. Luckily there are enough of us who refuse to "grow up".
End of quote


Agreed! Thank heavens some of us do!
Reply #23 Top
Sesame street doesn't hold my son's attention.


Children's programming has come a long way. There's a lot better stuff out there than Sesame Street nowadays. Sesame Street seems to be an ADD-type show, always flipping from one unrelated segment to another. I've tried to find a theme across the segments, and they sure try to convince the viewer that there's a theme by telling you what the letter-or-number of the day is. Bah. I think anyone who's susceptible to ADD is better off seeking edu-tainment elsewhere.

Oh, and Elmo gives me a headache. But I sure can identify with that Oscar fellow.

By the way, my four-year-old son is now reading and writing, no thanks to anything on TV! Whoopeeee! But I confess that we're suckers for the internet. PBSkids.org is absolutely terrific. Especially WordGirl and Wayne's Word. It's inspired us to play spontaneous games like Word Jousting. He'll come at me with a "sword" and shout the first part of a word (like,"CR!"), then I come back at him with the other half of the word ("ASH!"), then we move in closer and closer until we meet and yell out the word together, ("CRASH!"). Of course we plan the word ahead of time before we start jousting so we both know how it'll go. It's all fun. OK, so we only did that once. But it was cool because he started it, and I can see that he's feeling the magic of literacy!
Reply #24 Top
Yet another institution being attacked by PC wankers. Leave Sesame Street alone... Next they'll be asking Disney to put pants on Mickey and Donald... Wankers...
Reply #25 Top
Irony: The people who complain about Oscar are just like him.
End of quote


Green, bitchy muppets that live in trash cans? :P

~Zoo