What is an expensive burger? Favorite burgers and such...

How much is too much, or what makes food worth it?

This topic has been around a bit in the past, with reports in the last year or two of upscale restaurants that were all competing amongst themselves to offer the most expensive burger. During that run of articles I think prices of $1000 were among those mentioned in the articles as being "the most expensive."

The inspiration for this current article is a fairly regular craving for burgers from a relatively small chain outlet in my area. A nice little burgers and shake place known as Cheeburger Cheeburger. (Linked: here)

In our area, we also have an up-and-coming (at least they tout themselves so in the articles they clip and place on their walls. Articles from newspapers, both local and national in scope, and articles from trade magazines and others) burger restaurant that only does burgers. Burgers and fries, and softdrinks, but no shakes, no salads, no soup, no chicken and no vegetarian type products. That quickly growing chain is known as Five Guys Famous Burgers and Fries. (Linked here: here)

Having dined at both places multiple times, my personal preference is for Cheeburger Cheeburger. There's more variety in their burger sizes, more choices for levels of "done-ness," and if you are so inclined, more choices for burger toppings. I'm also a huge fan of their fries (which they provide generous amounts of, no matter what size you order) which I think taste a little better than Five Guys fries do (though I'll give credit to the quantity of fries that are given to you by Five Guys, no matter what size you order they give you a ton of them, way more than are needed. A meal unto themselves if you wanted them that way!).

Both places charge similar prices for their food, though Cheeburger Cheeburger has more flexibility with the various sized burgers, and the other menu choices they offer (chicken, salads, shakes, etc.), and the prices are part of what bring this article up.

I don't personally believe the prices are bad at either place. They may be bad compared to say McDonalds, Burger King, or Wendy's, but the food is multiples better quality and taste wise. Where you'll pay approximately $6 for a 1/3 pound burger at Cheeburger Cheeburger, versus $2.99 for a value meal (or similarly priced) that includes a McDonalds Quarter Pounder with Cheese, the food you get is more recognizable, cooked to order, and not the overly processed and bland products that require a big squirt of some secret sauce to give the thing a little flavor.

My wife on the other hand, though she enjoys the food we get at Cheeburger complains when the bill hits the table and she realizes we've just spent approximately $50 (including tip) for a family of four to go out for food. Certainly it's not more expensive than a place like say The Olive Garden, Outback, Red Lobster, or a batch of other places. Most of those places would be more expensive by about $10 - $20 (by the time we include tips) depending on whether we order appetizers, deserts, and such.

My wife's complaint is easily summarized as "$50 for burgers!?!" while the rest of the family is still enjoying the taste of the food.

In anycase, I'm curious what the consensus is on "how much is too much" for a burger. What's your breaking point on how much you're willing to pay for what you consider a good burger?
5,265 views 9 replies
Reply #1 Top
I don't think I would ever spend more than $10 for a burger dinner. I have never been to either restaurant you mentioned. I don't know that they have them in my corner of Texas. Ususally if I go out to eat it's not for burgers. I like to go out for things that I can't make at home.

We have a local hamburger joint called Skinny's. They have the best burgers - yum. And the guy who works there is always super nice to me which is an added bonus. I have to get the skinny mini, you know because I'm so petite and have such a small appetite - ha. But the regular skinny is just huge and I can't finish it. I think it's half a pound. If anyone ever comes by Weatherford, Texas stop and have a burger at Skinny's. The only bad thing is that we live in a dry town (!?!) so if you want a beer with your burger you're going to have to take it home.

Plus there's just something about the personality of a locally owned restaurant. I do like the food at many of the chains but sometimes you just get tired of eating at a place that could be anywhere, USA.

Oh and my favorite way to make burgers at home is to fry them and then top them with American cheese and tomato soup. It is a yummy, gloppy mess. No bun of course. You have to eat it with a fork.
Reply #2 Top
See, I'm with LW. If I want cheap, I order a bag of them. If they get too pricey, I fire up the grill and make my own. I KNOW my produce is fresh!
Reply #3 Top
I like the roadside, drive-in "Burger & a Malt" type places. My favorite local burger place is called "Cruisers"... probably nothing real special about it, other than the burger doesn't feel like shoeleather, the buns are "Sheboygan Hard Rolls" and it is adjacent to a Harley Shop... what could be better ;~D
Reply #4 Top
Here's a $5K burger:

FleurBurger 5000 - the world’s most expensive burger

Looking for the ultimate burger experience? Then go to Fleur de Lys at Las Vegas’ Mandalay Bay. The FleurBurger 5000 is the creation of renowned chef Hubert Keller; it’s a Kobe burger topped with foie gras and black truffles, served on a brioche truffle bun and garnished with a special sauce (containing yet more truffles). It comes with a bottle of Chateau Pétrus 1990 in Ichendorf Brunello stemware (exclusively imported from Italy). You get to keep the glassware but then, at $5000 a time, so you should.


Found at:
Link


As for me--you can't really get a meal around here (with tax and tip included) for under $10 in a restaurant, so I'd probably pay around $12 to $15 for a burger. Though I admit that I don't eat them often--I'm more a chicken kind of girl.
Reply #5 Top
Be a cold day in hell when I pay a hundred bucks for a burger
Reply #6 Top
Whip - it looks like Shades did us the favor of finding the link for the expensive burger. I didn't remember the exact price, just that there was an article about some super expensive burger that was receiving some pub last year. Thanks much Shades for finding the link and the correct pricing. Expensive sucker for sure.

Now, in defense of my favorite burger joint, I know I could do as Whip or Gid suggests, just go buy a pound of burger (or a few pounds) and cook it myself. I could also buy a big sack of spuds, slice 'em and dice 'em as necessary, and cook 'em up. Here's the the thing though, I'm no genius at math, but I think the math is actually closer to being in my favor than you guys might think.

The place I prefer uses premium quality Black Angus beef. Ground sirloin, not crappy ground beef. Stuff that would easily cost me near $6 a pound (if memory of ground beef pricing serves).

When I order a Cheeburger burger, I get the 1/2 pound burger. That burger is actually 12 oz. pre-cooked weight, so it's 3/4 pound before it's cooked down. That means if I make a 1/3 pound burger for my wife, I'd need 8 oz. of beef pre-cooked weight. I'd be at about a pound and a half of beef to make the couple of burgers. Never mind finding fresh rolls, fresh lettuce and tomato for the wife's toppings, sauteed mushrooms for hers, a couple of onion rings for hers, and cheese for both of us.

I figure food cost alone is about 2/3rds of the cost for the burgers I get a Cheeburger.

I know I could get cheap frozen patties, or even some healthier beef without hormones and steroids that isn't that expensive, but still runs about $7 for a pound and a half.

Add in some top quality milk shakes -- genuine shakes, not McDonalds mystery soquid type things, and the costs go up, but so does the satisfaction.


Don't get me wrong, I eat more than my share of cheap food, but then again I try to buy better quality stuff, and stick to some name brands where I know I'm getting better quality for it. Every now and then (about once every two weeks) I just enjoy letting someone else cook me a good burger, as compared to staying at home and cooking a grill cheese, or maybe a box of 'burger helper.
Reply #7 Top
BTW, a few other burger places I have frequented and enjoy:

Steak and Shake (linked here). Decent burgers, good shakes, shoe-string fries that I am not a huge fan of. Pricing not that far off from what you'd find at Five Guys or Cheeburger. Maybe a little cheaper, but not much. Mostly found (by me at least) off interstates. Last time visited was in a location at Daytona, Florida.

Johnny Rockets (linked here). I like their burgers pretty well, fries that are a bit more "meaty" (bulkier, more standard cut), but which really don't leave me feeling unsatisfied if I miss 'em. Shakes also a specialty. Pricey, at least in line with Cheeburger or Five guys, and really not better and not worth paying more for. Only real advantage is they normally have 60s and 70s era songs on jukebox selections you can listen to. Mostly found in malls. Last time visited, a few weeks ago when playing chaperone for a field trip for my daughters school class.

Whataburger (linked: here). Most familiar with them from visiting while working in Texas for a few months back in the 1990's. I'd rate them at the higher end of fast food burgers, at least for my tastes. Much better than McDonalds or Burger King (to my tastes). Cheap, filling, quick. Last visited back in 1999

Fuddruckers (link: here). Was my families previous favorite burger joint before giving Cheeburger Cheeburger a try. Same price range, same basic menu. Still a good place to go for us, though I like the fries better at Cheeburger. (Fudd's typically has steak cut fries, bigger, thicker cuts. Excellent seasoning/taste to them also, just different than Cheeburgers. Fudds fries are excellent with Ketchup though, great for dipping in same, and always come up hot and fresh for me when visiting). Last visited about 6 - 8 months ago.


One other place I enjoy burgers from: Duclaw Brewing Co. (link: here) Good taste, cooked to my liking. Moist, yet meaty. Only one size available (by memory). Note that my tastes for their burgers is not influenced by their other products. While I'm not completely abhorrent towards beer, I'm not a big beer drinker either. I'll get one of the house specialties about every other time I'm there, and only have one. Most of the time I go for Iced Tea.


These are just a few places I've been for burgers. I could add Chili's (chain restaurant). They have good burgers also, but are no cheaper than any of the other places listed here.
Reply #8 Top
if I'm not making them myself, my favorite burgers are from White Castle, aka 'sliders.'


Ah, now you remind me of Harold and Kumar and NPH riding along in the back of their car!

(If you haven't seen that movie, get it as a rental and laugh your butt off at it, it's great!)
Reply #9 Top
I was going to mention Fuddruckers, but you got that one.  I think (after my next LDL test), I will go with Gideon tho and fire up the grill.  and just ask each and every one 'Wel done, medium, rare, or just stopped mooing?'